Heating oil vs propane: equivalent prices
Why a gallon of oil isn’t a gallon of propane, with a state comparison table.
In the Northeast and parts of the Midwest, heating oil and propane compete for the same homes, the ones beyond the gas mains. A gallon of oil holds about 50% more heat than a gallon of propane, so comparing price per gallon is misleading.
Equivalent prices
Heating oil contains 138,500 Btu per gallon; propane 91,452. Oil boilers and furnaces usually run 80–87% efficient; new propane furnaces can reach 95%. With an 85% oil system against a 95% propane furnace:
propane matches oil when: propane price = oil price ÷ 1.36
So $4.00 heating oil in an 85% boiler costs the same per unit of heat as propane at $2.95 in a 95% furnace. With equal efficiencies, the ratio is 1.51.
States where EIA surveys both
| State | Heating oil $/gal | Propane $/gal | Oil price that matches this propane | Cheaper per Btu |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Connecticut | $5.45 | $4.41 | $5.98 | Heating oil |
| Delaware | $5.89 | $3.97 | $5.38 | Propane |
| Indiana | $5.60 | $2.73 | $3.70 | Propane |
| Iowa | $5.19 | $1.79 | $2.43 | Propane |
| Kentucky | $5.64 | $2.93 | $3.97 | Propane |
| Maine | $5.69 | $3.68 | $4.99 | Propane |
| Maryland | $6.07 | $3.96 | $5.36 | Propane |
| Massachusetts | $5.68 | $3.82 | $5.18 | Propane |
| Michigan | $5.52 | $2.54 | $3.45 | Propane |
| Minnesota | $5.30 | $2.18 | $2.95 | Propane |
| Nebraska | $5.11 | $1.84 | $2.50 | Propane |
| New Hampshire | $5.74 | $3.90 | $5.28 | Propane |
| New Jersey | $5.85 | $4.12 | $5.58 | Propane |
| New York | $5.97 | $3.82 | $5.18 | Propane |
| North Carolina | $5.62 | $3.76 | $5.10 | Propane |
| Ohio | $5.70 | $2.82 | $3.81 | Propane |
| Pennsylvania | $5.55 | $3.27 | $4.43 | Propane |
| Rhode Island | $5.68 | $4.12 | $5.59 | Propane |
| Vermont | $5.62 | $3.99 | $5.41 | Propane |
| Virginia | $5.75 | $3.79 | $5.14 | Propane |
| Wisconsin | $5.25 | $2.13 | $2.89 | Propane |
Other differences
- Efficiency ceiling: condensing propane furnaces and boilers reach the mid-90s; most oil equipment stays in the 80s.
- Storage: oil tanks are usually indoors or buried, unpressurized, and often owned by the homeowner. Propane tanks are pressurized and often leased from the supplier.
- Maintenance: oil systems typically need annual cleaning and nozzle and filter replacement; propane burns cleaner.
- Price behavior: heating oil tracks diesel and global crude markets. Propane tracks the natural gas liquids market and can spike regionally in very cold winters when inventories are low.
- Blends: many dealers sell bioheat (heating oil blended with biodiesel), which works in most existing oil equipment at lower blends.
If you're replacing an oil system anyway, compare a heat pump too. In many Northeastern states the cost per Btu of oil is well above a heat pump's at typical COPs. Run your numbers in the calculator.