Heating equipment is rated with different efficiency numbers depending on what it burns or how it works. Knowing what each rating means, and what it leaves out, is the key to comparing a furnace with a heat pump.

AFUE: furnaces and boilers

Annual Fuel Utilization Efficiency is the share of the fuel's energy that a furnace or boiler turns into heat over a typical season, including startup and cycling losses. A 95% AFUE furnace converts 95% of the fuel's heat; the rest leaves through the vent.

  • About 80%: standard non-condensing gas and propane furnaces, vented through a metal flue or chimney.
  • 90% to 98%: condensing furnaces. They cool the exhaust enough to condense water vapor and recover its heat, and they vent through plastic pipe.
  • About 80% to 87%: most oil furnaces and boilers.
  • 56% to 70%: older low-efficiency systems, according to the U.S. Department of Energy, often units with a standing pilot light and natural draft.

AFUE is measured at the appliance. It doesn't count heat lost from ducts in an unheated attic or crawlspace, or the electricity the blower motor uses. If your ducts run through unconditioned space, real-world efficiency can be noticeably lower.

COP: heat pumps at a moment in time

A heat pump doesn't burn anything. It uses electricity to move heat from outdoor air (or the ground) into the house. Its coefficient of performance is heat delivered divided by electricity used, in the same units. A COP of 3 means three units of heat for each unit of electricity: effectively 300% efficient.

COP is not fixed. An air-source heat pump might run at COP 3.5 or more around 47°F and fall below 2 near 5°F, because there is less heat to pull from colder air. ENERGY STAR's cold-climate heat pump criteria require a COP of at least 1.75 at 5°F. Below its operating range, or when it can't keep up, a heat pump relies on backup heat. That backup is often electric resistance strips at COP 1, or a furnace in a "dual-fuel" setup.

HSPF and HSPF2: heat pumps over a season

The Heating Seasonal Performance Factor rates a heat pump over a standardized heating season, in Btu of heat per watt-hour of electricity, including some backup heat. Divide by 3.412 to turn it into an average COP:

seasonal COP ≈ HSPF ÷ 3.412

Since 2023, new equipment is rated under the updated HSPF2 test, which uses more realistic conditions and gives lower numbers than the old HSPF for the same unit. An HSPF2 of 8.0 works out to a seasonal COP of about 2.3 under the test's climate assumptions. In Minnesota, northern New England, or the northern Plains, expect lower seasonal performance than the label climate unless the unit is a cold-climate model sized for the house.

What to enter in the calculator

EquipmentReasonable planning value
Condensing gas or propane furnace0.92 – 0.96
Standard gas or propane furnace0.78 – 0.80
Furnace 25+ years old0.60 – 0.70
Oil boiler or furnace0.80 – 0.87
Air-source heat pump, mild wintersCOP 2.8 – 3.3
Cold-climate heat pump, cold wintersCOP 2.0 – 2.6
Ground-source heat pumpCOP 3.0 – 4.0
Electric baseboard or electric furnace1.00

If you know the model, look up its rating in the manual, on the yellow EnergyGuide label, or in the AHRI directory, then adjust for your climate. The calculator suggests a heat pump COP based on how cold your state is, and you can change it.

Why a 95% furnace can still cost more than a COP-2.5 heat pump

Efficiency is only half of the cost equation; the other half is price per Btu. Electricity costs far more per Btu than gas, so a heat pump has to deliver well over one unit of heat per unit of electricity just to break even. Whether it wins depends on your local prices. See heat pump vs propane and cost per million Btu.